Café de olla — "coffee from the pot" — is Mexico's most beloved traditional coffee. It's brewed with cinnamon and piloncillo (unrefined cane sugar), often with a hint of orange peel or clove, in a clay pot called an olla de barro. The clay pot matters less for flavor than tradition, but the spiced coffee inside is something special: warm, caramelly, and deeply comforting. Here's how to make it the authentic way.
What Makes It Different
Most flavored coffee gets its character from syrups or flavored beans added at the end. Café de olla is different: the spices brew with the coffee, so the cinnamon and caramel notes are woven into the cup rather than sitting on top of it. The piloncillo — a cone of dark, smoky cane sugar — gives it a molasses depth that white sugar can't match. If you can't find piloncillo, dark brown sugar is the closest substitute.
The Authentic Recipe (Serves 4)
Ingredients: - 4 cups water - 1 cone (about 8 oz) piloncillo, or 1 cup dark brown sugar - 1 large cinnamon stick (Ceylon if you can find it) - 2–3 strips of orange peel (optional but recommended) - 1–2 whole cloves (optional) - 4 tablespoons coarsely ground coffee (French press grind)
Steps:
- Bring the water, piloncillo, cinnamon, orange peel, and cloves to a gentle boil in a large pot. Stir until the sugar fully dissolves.
- Reduce to a simmer for 5 minutes so the spices infuse the water.
- Add the coffee grounds, stir once, and remove from heat. Cover and steep for 5 minutes.
- Strain through a fine mesh sieve or cheesecloth into a pitcher. Serve hot.
The Clay Pot Question
The olla de barro — an unglazed clay pot — is the traditional vessel, and devotees swear it adds an earthy roundness to the brew. If you have one, great. If not, any pot works; the spices do the heavy lifting. Clay is porous and retains seasoning from previous brews, similar to how a well-used French press or clay teapot develops character over time.
Best Coffee for Café de Olla
You want a medium-bodied coffee with natural chocolate and spice notes that won't fight the cinnamon. The Mexican Chocolate flavored coffee leans into the same flavor family for an extra-decadent version, and Mexican single origins show up in our best-sellers sample pack. For a more traditional cup, the mellow Colombia or nutty Brazil Santos both brew beautifully with spices.
One note on grind: coarse grounds are essential, since you're steeping and straining rather than filtering through paper. If you're between grinder settings, check our grind size guide — too fine and the cup turns muddy.
When to Serve It
Café de olla is breakfast coffee, afternoon coffee, and — with a splash of coffee liqueur — after-dinner coffee. It pairs naturally with pan dulce, churros, or anything cinnamon-adjacent. And if you love spiced holiday drinks, it's a natural cousin of the gingerbread latte.
Spice up your coffee shelf — take 10% off with code WELCOME10.
